
True or false? Christians are still poor miserable sinners who deserve only God’s wrath and punishment.
Asked another way, what is the Christian identity? The reality of sin in the life of Christians before the backdrop of God’s promises of love and full forgiveness presents a paradox believers throughout the ages have struggled to accurately articulate.
Which one is it? Are we holy in God’s sight through faith in Christ? Or are we sinners in God’s sight deserving divine judgment? And how do we reconcile the answer with our lived experiences?
Retired pastor Mark Cares has wrestled with these questions for decades on a deeply practical and theological level. The results of his wrestling with Scripture and seeking to minister to Christians in a faithful way led to the writing of his book, Christian, Who Are You? Your Amazing God-Given Identity.
The book has two parts: 1) Your Wonderful Status and 2) Your Wonderful New State. Distinguishing the status and state of a believer in Jesus is critical to the main purpose of the book, and he carefully defines both status and state from key Bible passages: A Christian’s status is who they are in relationship with God and his law; a Christian’s state is what they do and experience (12). Christians were sinners, he says, who now are God’s holy people, given a new status and identity (23-24). Even as Christians continue to sin, their new state is a wonderful one connected to God and all his certain promises (91-92).
Cares argues that Christians far too often view themselves from a significantly lower viewpoint than God does (45), and he would like to see that change. By carefully walking through the Bible’s various ways of describing a person before conversion and after conversion, he paints the before and after pictures. Before conversion, a person was a miserable sinner, deserving of God’s wrath and punishment. After conversion, a believer in Jesus is God’s holy child, forgiven, loved, and an heir of heaven with a tremendous purpose in life. He encourages seeing and cherishing the after picture for what it is and not letting the before picture dominate as if it were still the only present reality.
Each chapter concludes with a summary of key points and suggestions for reflection. Two insightful appendices explore more difficult topics in further detail. An accompanying study guide for the book is also available online.
I am grateful that Mark Cares wrote this book for many reasons. Here are some of the more significant ones.
Careful Bible interpretation
Cares presents concepts that are, at times, challenging. He does so, however, with the utmost reverence for the Bible as the source of truth. He consistently references grammar and context as he elaborates on a point a particular passage teaches. In fact, taking seriously verb tenses in passages like Ephesians chapter two is critical to his understanding of the Christian identity (23). He examines key biblical terms as if learning them for the first time, breathing new life to concepts like sinners and the righteous, repentance, the flesh/sinful nature, and the image of God. His insights on the overwhelming majority of times the Bible describes believers in positive, rather than condemning, terms underscore the way he lets the Bible shape his arguments and offers encouragement to his readers.
While Cares may leave you stumped at times, it isn’t because you can’t see how he got that difficult thought from the Bible. Instead, he’ll leave you scratching your head at what the Bible says, and how it says it. The difficult mental journey is worth it, though, as it leads to deeper biblical insight and spiritual renewal.
Enlightenment on the sinner-saint dilemma
The concept of Christians being at the same time sinners and saints is helpful, though not always easy to understand or articulate. Cares’s explanations of the pre-converted self and the post-converted believer brought this to light in ways I have never encountered before. Rather than portraying an inner sinner and saint as two equal foes within a Christian, he accentuates the Bible’s teaching that believers in Christ are saints. Period. That’s the Christian’s identity or status. When it comes to the present state we live in, he says the believer in Christ is a “saint who still sins” (46). While the flesh and spirit are both present in a believer, he contends (from texts like Romans chapters seven and eight) that the flesh and spirit are not equals: “Our flesh, our sinful nature, remains in us, but it no longer reigns in us . . . The spirit, not the flesh, is what controls believers” (112).
Further explanation about the origin of the sinner-saint term from Martin Luther is in the appendix of the book, along with thoughts on its proper use today. Such enlightening research is immensely helpful for daily Christian living, for preaching and teaching, and for carefully applying the Word in ways that are tight to Scripture’s vocabulary and model.
Examination of guilt’s usefulness for believers
While the law certainly maintains vital usefulness in the life of a believer, Cares examines whether the purpose of the law in a believer’s life ought to continually produce guilt. As he carefully distinguishes the status and state of a believer, Cares demonstrates how God changes our status to not guilty and keeps it that way. While the law exposes sin, it does not condemn believers as if they are continually falling in and out of grace with God, constantly jeopardizing their salvation: “[Passages exposing sin] are talking about something we do, not who we are. Every time a believer sins, God is not changing their legal status to guilty. ‘There is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus’ (Romans 8:1). When we are in Christ, we remain justified (not guilty) even when we sin” (39).
Therefore, Cares argues, if believers have a solid declaration of innocence from the almighty Judge, they should combat guilt, not foster it. While it may seem pious to harbor feelings of guilt and inadequacy, such an approach doesn’t please God. Instead, he says, the gospel calls for confidence in our justification, pushing back against guilt that questions and undermines what Christ perfectly accomplished for us.
Delight in the gospel
Throughout the book, the author continually exudes an undimmable delight in the gospel. From the beginning, his purpose is clear: to let the good news of Christ be all that it is, and to not let anything minimize the all-surpassing greatness of our new identity in Christ. Cares shines the light on the multi-faceted beauty of the gospel from every angle he can. He won’t allow the readers to brush too quickly past the astounding event of their conversions. He proclaims the greatness of God’s love and his power at work in us, leading to an astounding calling and purpose for believers.
The book is motivational and inspiration in all the right ways. This makes it a refreshing read among much modern Chrisitan literature. Interestingly, in a book all about the Christian’s personal identity, his constant encouragement is to stop focusing on self and instead on God and who he says we are (79). That’s the greatest inspiration there is! From beginning to end, Cares shares his joy in the gospel, a joy that is wonderfully contagious.
Because of the fresh perspectives and appropriate challenges to typical ways of thinking, readers of Christian, Who Are you? by Mark Cares will at times desire more application and examples of what it looks like for a believer to internalize the truths he exposits. Or, borrowing from the principles of show biz, perhaps he purposely wanted to keep his readers wanting more. (And maybe a follow-up book is in the works? One can hope.) In any case, this book is an essential read for all Christians who want to go deeper in their faith in Christ and who want to embrace more fully their amazing, God-given identity.